“Incompetence, racism and prejudice delayed my diagnosis”
Women and Parkinson's
Author: Manon DayPublished: 23 January 2020
Prep: Cook: Serves:
It took a decade for Manon Day to be diagnosed with
Parkinson’s – with clinicians treating her as though she was a drug addict,
causing her to feel “mistreated” and “powerless”. She explains the role being a
young black woman played in her delayed diagnosis – and why “we need more
awareness to break the myths and stereotypes” around who the condition affects
My Parkinson’s symptoms started at the age of 17, but it
wasn’t until 10 years later that I was diagnosed with the condition, aged 27.
Over the years, I was living with uncertainty and was
worried about my physical state. At first, I struggled with low blood pressure
and I was fainting several times a week. Now, my symptoms include stiffness,
difficulty moving, speech problems, bladder dysfunction, fatigue and more.
When I was officially diagnosed with Parkinson’s in 2011,
I was overwhelmed and in shock – it had taken a decade to get the right
diagnosis. I knew for sure that Parkinson’s was going to change everything.
Women are less likely to be diagnosed with Parkinson’s
compared to men. Being a young black woman played a huge role in my delayed
diagnosis. The neurologists I initially consulted stigmatised me. They didn’t
believe me when I explained my symptoms: they thought I was a drug addict. I
was mistreated and my experience was horrible. It reached the point where I
became very ill and could not walk because my body was so stiff. Racism was the
cause of my delayed diagnosis and I felt powerless.
Due to incompetence and prejudice, I did not receive the
medical care that I so desperately needed. Every time the paramedics rushed me
to the hospital emergency room, the neurologists sent me back home right away.
Consequently, I felt distressed and abandoned by the healthcare system.
I changed hospitals and thankfully, as of now, I receive the best medical care and treatment at the Montreal Neurological Institute and Hospital. I have had an excellent response to levodopa and through medication, diet and exercise, I’m managing my Parkinson’s.
“It’s a devastating diagnosis to receive in the
prime of your life”
When I told my family about my diagnosis, they were stunned, as we thought that the condition usually afflicts the elderly. We started researching it intensely. Although my movement disorder specialist gave me lots of information about Parkinson’s, I had no knowledge about how the condition affects women in general – for example how I experience more symptoms of rigidity and slowness during my periods.
There were several challenges related to my young onset
diagnosis: I couldn’t pursue my studies in the field of translation, and I
chose not to conceive children because pregnancy is a risk to my health. In
addition to my Parkinson’s, I live with a second rare disease called acromegaly,
which I was diagnosed with in 2014. It’s a hormonal disorder that affects
approximately 2,000 people in Canada. It’s a damaging and incurable disease and,
as far as I know, I am the only person in the world living with both young
onset Parkinson’s and acromegaly.
Parkinson’s has also had negative effects on my hobbies and social life – it’s a devastating diagnosis to receive in the prime of your life when you are full of plans for the future.
“Parkinson’s doesn’t only affect old Caucasian
Generally speaking, women and people from minority backgrounds are underrepresented in the Parkinson’s research community. I am registered in a clinical Parkinson’s trial database called the Quebec Parkinson’s Network because I want to be involved and share my experience to advance knowledge in the scientific community. I think playing a small role can have a positive impact in the development of future therapies.
I’ve never met other black men or women with Parkinson’s in Montreal – and while I’m in contact with a few people online, I don’t know the details of their personal stories. It’s a sad reality that minorities face several challenges to get diagnosed correctly with Parkinson’s. That’s why three years ago I created a Facebook group called Everything about Parkinson’s Disease to connect with fellow patients, young or old – and of different races. It now has over 9,000 members worldwide. Running the group gives me a sense of purpose and I’m very happy to make a difference in people’s lives.
We need more awareness to break the myths and stereotypes around the condition. Parkinson’s doesn’t only affect old Caucasian men. It can impact anyone, regardless of age or ethnicity.
Need to know: Manon Day is 35 years old and lives in Montreal, Canada. She was diagnosed with Parkinson’s in 2011, age 27, and subsequently quit her studies in translation. She is now a Parkinson’s campaigner and runs a Facebook group called Everything about Parkinson’s Disease to raise awareness of the condition and how it can affect people of all backgrounds.
The facts: who does Parkinson’s affect?
Parkinson’s affects people of all racial and ethnic backgrounds and cultures
Around 10 million people across the globe live with the condition – and by 2040, it is estimated that there will be 13 million people with Parkinson’s
Our ‘In My Country’ series features interviewees from organisations around the world to spotlight the differing experiences of and attitudes towards people with Parkinson’s globally
Women and Parkinson’s: Our campaign
It is estimated that three million women worldwide are living with Parkinson’s – yet their specific needs and experiences are often ignored, leading to disparities in diagnosis, treatment and medication. Each week, we’ll be sharing the little-heard stories of women with the condition to find out how their lives are being affected by a shocking data gap when it comes to women and Parkinson’s. This is just the start.
We want to raise awareness of women’s experience of the condition within the medical profession, so that women’s symptoms are taken seriously.
We think more research is needed into the impact of Parkinson’s on women, so that they can benefit from tailored medication and treatment.
We want to explore ways to offer better support for those women managing the condition alongside caring responsibilities.
Join us – #WomenAndParkinsons.
For more information on women and Parkinson’s please visit the EPDA website.
If you have a story to tell about being a woman with Parkinson’s – or some information about the impact of the condition on women for us to share with the global Parkinson’s community – please get in touch.
Together, apart: tune in to a World Parkinson’s Day video event
A chance for people with Parkinson's disease to “learn and get inspired"
7 days ago
Could virtual studies support Parkinson’s disease research?
Parkinson’s research is “hampered by inefficient recruitment and burdensome in-person assessments”, according to researchers in the US and Canada. But could virtual research have the potential to help solve some of these problems? Recruiting 203 participants from Fox Insight – an online clinical study sponsored by The Michael J Fox Foundation – the team assessed the validity of the participants’ self-reported Parkinson’s health information, and their willingness to take part in video-based research. Participants completed online questionnaires and attended two virtual visits, with a movement disorder specialist determining the likely diagnosis compared to the self-reported diagnosis. The study revealed that the participants’ self-reported diagnosis of Parkinson’s was accurate – and that 98.5% of participants would consider participating in a future study with virtual visits. The researchers concluded: “Our study demonstrates the promise of a much-needed novel model for conducting Parkinson’s research and highlights the potential of such a model for ……
2 weeks ago
Gait and tremor may be the best early predictors of Parkinson’s disease
Gait and tremor may be the most identifiable early signs of Parkinson’s disease, according to researchers from the US, France and Germany. The researchers analysed data from two large health-record databases, including an insurance company’s de-identified administrative claims. Selecting 8,382 participants with Parkinson’s disease, the scientists evaluated individual occurrences of reported symptoms over time – and how these corresponded to their Parkinson’s diagnosis. The analysis revealed a “pre-diagnostic window” in which symptoms were reported but no diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease was made. The most dominant symptoms in this pre-diagnostic window were abnormal gait and tremor, highlighting “the existence of a population of [Parkinson’s] patients whose diagnoses can be accelerated”. The researchers concluded: “Accurate, prospective identification of high-risk individuals would allow for earlier diagnosis, intervention and more effective large-scale evaluation of potential therapeutics.”
3 weeks ago
Air pollution may be linked to greater risk of Parkinson’s disease
A study from researchers in South Korea suggests that exposure to nitrogen dioxide (NO2), a gas associated with car and power plant emissions, could increase the risk of Parkinson’s disease. Using Korean National Health Insurance Service data, the researchers identified 78,830 participants above age 40 who had lived in Seoul during a certain time frame – and had not been diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease before 2006. During the study period of January 2007 to December 2015, 338 of the participants were diagnosed with the condition. The team then used participant addresses to determine the degree of air pollution exposure. The analysis revealed that those with the highest NO2 exposure had a “statistically significant” greater risk of being diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease. “These findings suggest that regulation of air pollutants might reduce the incidence of Parkinson’s disease,” wrote the researchers, “advocating for the need to implement a targeted public health policy.”