Doctors thought I had Parkinson’s for nearly a decade – they were wrong


Author: Joanne ClementsPublished: 29 September 2016

Parkinson's LifePrep: Parkinson's LifeCook: Parkinson's LifeServes:

What’s it like to live with Parkinson’s disease – with all the strong drugs and their debilitating side effects – only to be told you were misdiagnosed, nearly 10 years later? Joanne Clements recalls her unique life-changing experience of misdiagnosis and the huge impact it’s had on her health

Symptoms arrived suddenly when I was placed under anaesthetic in March 2006 and failed to wake up properly. Afterwards, I couldn’t remember how to move my arms and legs. I saw a neurologist quite quickly as I was manifesting a wide range of neurological symptoms – clumsiness, stumbling, difficulty reading or responding normally, tripping over things and moving slowly.

Within weeks I was diagnosed with “likely Parkinson’s disease” by a consultant neurologist. And initially, albeit briefly, responded well to Sinemet – a combination of carbidopa and levodopa used to treat Parkinson’s – which I started taking in August 2006.

From about 2008 I began to wonder about how well I was doing and actually thought the exercises I was doing and the way I was managing things was keeping the disease at bay, while secretly hoping, of course, that I didn’t have the disease.

During this time the neurospecialist I saw would comment on how well I was doing, that there were no fundamental signs of the disease – I assumed this because I was well-medicated – and other neurological symptoms I was reporting weren’t apparently associated with Parkinson’s. But it wasn’t until 2014-15 that I had a DaT Scan (imaging technology that uses small amounts of a radioactive drug to help determine how much dopamine is available in a person’s brain), which then showed no damage to, or impairment of the dopamine transporter system – proving I didn’t have Parkinson’s.

Relief versus confusion

In a sense the certainty of diagnosis was good – I ‘belonged’ somewhere, having helped Parkinson’s UK review pamphlets, attended some of their workshops and getting friends involved with fundraising for Cure Parkinson’s Trust. I felt I had a support network of people who understood my condition.

Once my diagnosis was no longer Parkinson’s, this entire network fell away – I no longer belonged in the world of Parkinson’s patients. Since May 2015 I have been entirely on my own again but with almost all the same neurological symptoms, as well as some new ones.

“In a sense the certainty of diagnosis was good – I ‘belonged’ somewhere”



I still have no confirmed diagnosis. The swathe of neurological symptoms still persist today – some aspects of movement are identified as functional movement disorder, but otherwise it has been a question of ruling in/out alternative causes for some symptoms.

One theory is that an initial brain insult during the 2006 anaesthetic, together with a gastro drug I was taking at the time that has Parkinsonism as a side effect, combined to give me Parkinson’s disease. But now this original brain insult (possibly a mini-stroke) plus nine years of my brain’s neuroplasticity being driven into new behaviours by Parkinson’s drugs, plus issues that arose during Parkinson’s drug withdrawal are the current neurological problems that I have to contend with.

Fortunately, while there is widespread dysfunction, I have been told that there does not appear to be any brain disease processes associated with these symptoms. Again, there are no tests to prove/disprove this and one remains reliant on the expertise of brilliant neuroscientists.

“A decade of unnecessary Parkinson’s drugs is likely to have remodelled my brain”

A key issue is that I no longer have a convenient label for my symptoms. I had pre-existing joint and gastro issues that have worsened immeasurably during the past decade. My ability to concentrate, to function, to move, to ‘be’ all worsened beyond comprehension. I have been told that nearly a decade of unnecessary Parkinson’s drugs is likely to have remodelled my brain, through its innate neuroplasticity, so that it now considers the symptomatic side effects of those drugs ‘normal’ for me. Just as hitting a tennis ball every day for 10 years will build up your ball-hitting skills, so the brain can be driven by drugs and their side effects into behaviours that it then reconfigures and learns as normal.

‘Writhing and contorting’

Actually weaning myself off Stalevo – a Parkinson’s medication used to increase dopamine levels in the brain – which I was taking eight times a day, was pretty terrifying. I was initially advised to drop one daily dose per week. By the second week I was writhing and contorting involuntarily – not something I had ever done before. I was then asked to drop one daily dose per month. I took my last Stalevo dose on 25 October 2015.

“I do my best to remain optimistic and cling to the fact that the Parkinson’s diagnosis is overturned”

Neurologists told me that the three drug components of Stalevo would be out of my system within a few weeks, but my brain only felt clear in February 2016 – four months after I’d stopped taking it. The huge range of motor and non-motor symptoms persists and other new ones have arrived since my body stopped receiving the added, yet unnecessary, dopamine. I do my best to remain optimistic and cling to the fact that the Parkinson’s diagnosis is overturned.


Look out for another article by Joanne in the coming weeks, discussing the issue of misdiagnosis in more depth. Joanne has written about her experiences on her blog here

Go Back

Share this story


  • Mike Bell

    Interesting that the scan proved ‘no PD’ – I had same scan results pre-DX, but then after positive results with Levodopa usage, after no reliable scan info, I was told I have Parkinson’s.

    • joannekarma

      I was at a point 10yrs after symptoms appeared and, at that stage, my NewNeuro said that there should be signs of damage in the dopamine transporter system. It is not a 100% reliable test but because parkinson’s disease is already at work before symptoms manifest, 10yrs after symptoms showing should certainly show damage in the dopamine system on DAT scan. How long have you been diagnosed? Is Levodopa really helping? these are the key issues, I gather!

  • Josie Dubbeldam

    I have something similar. I also have Parkinsonlike symptoms since 14th of april 2014. That day I had a Total knee replacement. I donot seem to feel Any effect of sinemet. Donot know what to do. My neurologist want to give me more levodopa.

    • joannekarma

      If the Sinemet /dopamine replacements is really NOT benefiting your movement at all, then loading up with more may not be the solution but you need to discuss this with your neuro. Perhaps instead of increasing your dose, maybe he/she would be happy for you to try halving it for a few days instead to see how it goes? Only ever tinker with your meds with his/her approval though 🙂

      • Allissa DeStefano

        My Grandfather showed signs of Parkinson’s for four and a half years before he was diagnosed almost three years ago. He responded to medication at first but it always made him sick. Three years later, I am watching my Grandfather lie helpless in a hospital bed. He has had a traumatic 10 months of finding blockages, aneurysm, heart attack etc. It wasn’t until now that I found out about “ParkinsonISM.” It shows signs and symptoms of the disease however is not Parkinson’s Disease. Therefore it does not need medication as the disease. Looking up cardidopa and levidopa toxicity and overdose, it is all the symptoms my grandfather has been having. All this time, his body was telling us all along, and we listened to Dr’s who told us his Parkinson’s was found so late on that is why he was experiencing what he was. When in fact. the medication was killing him. Dr’s practice medicine, they do not own it. It changes every single day and is based off of black and white text book. No one knows better than your own body. Listen to your body.

        • Anna-Maria Miraldi

          If not Parkinsons, may be Lymes disease? Het the Western blot test

  • Judy Hall

    I was told I had Parkinson’s a year ago. I had tremors, balance problems, swallowing problems, sometimes speech problems and memory problems etc. I was being seen by a Neurologist and sometimes his nurse practicianer. He put me on Senemet right away but I didn’t see much change so I had him take me off it. I also have neuropathy and some autoimmune diseases so symptoms could be overlaping from those also. I got tired of the Neuro always changing my diagnoses, from Parkinsons to essential tremors back to Parkinsons. I just went and got 2nd opinion from movement special and they said I have Parkinsonism and postural tremors but I don’t know what to believe.

  • Bonnie

    May I ask the name of the gastro drug you were taking in 2006 that has Parkinsonism as a side effect?

  • Grace

    I know someone who has been diagnosed with PD for 1.5 years and has been on dopamine drugs all this time but now a new neurologist who called for a DaT scan says he definitively does not have PD. He’s doing more testing now and thinks it may be hyperthyroidism. Perhaps you might want to also ask about testing for hyperthyroidism?

  • Jesse Akers

    Help me!!! My dad was at the family Dr. With my mom 5 years ago.Dr.commented you have Parkinson’s.why because he scoots his feet when walks.always have.short refered too neurologists office.they prescribed him the Parkinson drugs.with in two weeks he had symptoms.shaking.balance . I know my dad does not have it.I tell every doctor.nurse.mailman.anyone and everyone.they just look at me like I’m crazy.they all say nothing.I just saw this story today.Im all alone.helping him and my mom who is blind.any help.??? Thanks

  • No One Special

    My sister was diagnosed 4 years ago, and I know for a fact she does not have Parkinson’s, but she’s on these horrid meds that create Parkinson’s-like symptoms. It’s so incredibly defeating to not be listened to. I have talked my sister into getting a second opinion. I’m going to try to find someone who knows what they’re talking about. We lost our brother last year from medical negligence. These people we apparently trust with our lives are just people, and they make assumptions and come to wrong conclusions all the time. I just want to know how to get her off this junk she’s on, and what to expect as she’s transitioning.

  • Robert Johnson

    I was diagnosed with parkinson’s in 2015 based on a hand tremor. I have not developed much else except a slight head tremor. The neuro said was caused by the Sinemet and to cut my dosage by 1/4. I found out last year that a 2012 CT scan found an Adrenal tumor. I have been unable to get anyone interested in getting serious about checking for intermittent bouts of Pheochromocytoma. I have had problems with hypertension and afib for years and have occasional hyper nights where sleep is mostly impossible. I have been up working in my shop from midnight till first light this morning. I then used a weedeater till 8am when I stopped for breakfast. I detest Doctors almost as much as politicians. In my past I lost a thriving business because of a misdiagnosis. I had chronic appendicitis diagnosed as ulcers and was too ill to work for 2 years. 10 years ago I was diagnosed with a kidney tumor and told you have to start chemo right away, I said no and went to another urologist who removed a kidney stone. I doubt I would be alive had I done the chemo.

Related articles

Maura Ward


Globetrotting with Parkinson’s: ‘a wonderful world waiting to be explored’

Maura Ward shares her top tips for travelling with Parkinson’s



Who said what: QoTW 28.05.15

Our favourite quotes of the week from around the web


In my country

Improving Parkinson’s care in India’s largest city

The management of Parkinson’s in Mumbai holds many challenges