Campaigners condemn BBC’s ‘inaccurate’ portrayal of Parkinson’s

Perspectives

Author: Geoffrey ChangPublished: 8 September 2016

Parkinson's LifePrep: Parkinson's LifeCook: Parkinson's LifeServes:

One of Us

Campaigners complain to TV channel after a character in one of their drama series inaccurately describes Parkinson’s disease as terminal


Viewers of BBC drama ‘One of Us’ sent in complaints after one of the show’s characters with Parkinson’s disease inaccurately described his condition as terminal.

Though the BBC would not reveal how many complaints it received, it is understood some members of the 3.7 million-strong audience also objected to other ways in which Parkinson’s was portrayed during the third episode in a four-part series.

Parkinson’s is a progressive disorder – people can live for many years after the point of diagnosis – and is considered a long-term, chronic condition, rather than a terminal illness.

Barbara Williams, director of support and local networks at Parkinson’s UK, spoke of the “hugely important role” of the media to ensure Parkinson’s is portrayed accurately to the public.

She said: “The media have a hugely important role to play in disseminating factual information about Parkinson’s and a responsibility to make sure that the public are not misinformed. We would urge anyone speaking about Parkinson’s publicly to check the facts first, in order to portray the condition accurately.

“We know from our own research and what people tell us about their experiences of living with Parkinson’s that misconceptions about the condition can have a devastating impact on people’s emotional and mental wellbeing, so it is essential that information the public receives about the condition is correct.

Bill Douglas is the character with Parkinson's who is played by John Lynch

Bill Douglas is the character with Parkinson’s who is played by John Lynch

However, the writers of the show Jack and Harry Williams have hit back at criticism. They released a statement saying the way the character Bill Douglas, played by John Lynch, talked about the disease reflected his own experience.

They added: “One of Us is a fictional drama series and the way Bill talks about his Parkinson’s is a deliberate choice – he perceives it as a death sentence, an end to his way of life and sense of self.

“He uses the hyperbolic language to shock and punish his son. This extreme behaviour is integral to the plot of the final episode.”

The fourth and final episode airs on 13 September on BBC1.

Go Back

Share this story

Comments


  • Enid Day

    This same thing has happened with the American show, Brain Dead. One of the characters was described as having stage 4 terminal Parkinson’s with six months to live if he didn’t give the alien ants his brain.
    Don’t ask. Maybe it’s a new treatment.

Related articles


potato with cream of the cream cheese and salted salmon

Recipes & Nutrition

One-day menu for people with Parkinson’s featuring salmon baked potatoes

One-day menu ideas for easy-to-chew meal planning

READ MORE
Ray Kennedy Cup 2016 lead

Health & Fitness

Game on: your invite to Parkinson’s football ‘World Cup’

Forget Euro 2016 and the Copa, there’s another tournament in town

READ MORE
Parkinson's UK audit 2015 lead

PD in Practice

Over 1/3 of patients don’t receive enough info about Parkinson’s at diagnosis

Parkinson’s UK outlines key areas for improvement in care in audit

READ MORE